Quote:
Originally Posted by
filghy2
There are definitely some similarities with Jeremy Corbyn, though there is US no equivalent to the Brexit issue that dominated UK politics. It's a worry that Sanders seems to have the same tendency to stubbornness and poor judgement on some things - eg not being willing to back away from past praise of left-wing dictatorships.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
filghy2
The things he's said haven't been terrible but it plays into the wrong narrative. He can be very reasonable on foreign policy issues but he also has to worry about people to the left who might see criticism of left-wing dictatorships as a betrayal. In the long-run he probably should worry more about scaring people by not condemning the excesses of left-wing regimes clearly enough, particularly given the threats some of his supporters have made online.
Take for example this criticism of Xi of China by Bernie Sanders.
https://twitter.com/BernieSanders/st...74541596626944
The response that sticks out to me is "authoritarianism is when you do things American doesn't like" with nearly a thousand likes. There's tons of room to point out the U.S.' hypocrisy on all foreign policy issues. But is there room to question whether China has an authoritarian government? I actually think if Bernie can avoid saying anything that runs in a loop on fox news, there is nothing objectively scary about his foreign policy views.
He's also done a lot of good when it comes to the Israel-Palestine issue. He is boycotting the AIPAC conference, which many of the other candidates have decided to follow suit with. AIPAC frequently has Islamophobic speakers and promotes the sorts of policies that thwart a peaceful resolution on the Israel-Palestine issue. Pretty soon they will not be able to tout themselves as a "bipartisan" organization. He has also said he will cut aid to Israel or use that threat to deter human rights abuses. This is a reasonable and productive policy that could lead to results, but is it vitriolic enough for people with a hammer and sickle in their twitter profile?
The similarity between Corbyn and Sanders has less to do with their particular positions and more to do with how the people who like them view them. They are indispensable. There is no close substitute. They are pure beyond question and have lived lives of selfless sacrifice. People who criticize them must be motivated by pure self-interest or be corrupt. People who criticize them deserve to demonized and humiliated without restraint.