Re: IS RELIGION CHILD ABUSE?
Quote:
Originally Posted by J
what if a parent believes in punching their kids...why does belief suddenly make a behavior ok? and if so, whats the line?
I'm pretty certain that would be well over the line
Quote:
Originally Posted by J
what if a parent believed a kid needs to wear 9 coats in the summer because of a certain religious behavior the parent interprets? surely that would constitute child abuse for many people?
Yes, of course it would. Thankfully no religion does require children to wear 9 coats in summer!?
Quote:
Originally Posted by J
is there not a delicious slippery slope here?
Yes
Quote:
Originally Posted by J
and even if theres a defense that u believe in the religion, isnt that like having an insanity defense,
No. It is absolutely nothing like an insanity defence. Check the M'Naughton rules.
Quote:
Originally Posted by J
and saying well i really believed in such and such and thus i shouldnt be punished for torturing my kids...think about it...what limitations are there on parental lunacy so long that the parents believe in it?
Limitations, let me see... the law?
Quote:
Originally Posted by J
what if a parent is a pagan, believing in many gods, and they make the kids pray 1,000 times a day, to the carpet god, the lawn god, the school god, the pizza god, the lego god, etc. etc. seriously, u dont think its child abuse? wow...u know i recall hearing this bit from david cross, and while i always found it funny, now i find it kinda sad:
i think im gonna raise my kids to be amish...and i know the day will come when theylle ask me "mmm, daddy, how come u get to watch tv and everything and we have candles and are in the dark and get no tv" and ill say to them, well sweetie, thats easy, thats because ur amish, daddy isnt, and amish people dont watch tv or use electricity, daddy doesnt believe in that, u believe in it, now get to bed sweetie so u can wake up early and churn daddy breakfast;)
That is funny, but not half as funny as reading this shambles of a thesis.