I spy !!!
Printable View
I spy !!!
Both of those were also good anti-war films Dan... but I still hold All Quiet' to be a pinnacle achievement.
I remember being very impressed by the Erich Maria Remarque novel, many years ago. I’ve only seen the old Lewis Milestone cinematic version of 1930. I think there was another in the 70s, but I assume you’re talking about the most recent one? the one from this year, by Mimi Leder? Is it that good? I’ll check it out!
Nope - I'm talking about the Lewis Milestone. Okay it shows its age - and in the end the book is finer - but it is magnificent. But I've not seen the more recent one.
The trouble with modern war films is that - by and large - they cannot resist the sentimental. Look at Finding Private Ryan or Warhorse. The last was nauseatingly sweet. (There are honourable exceptions - The Thin Red line and Platoon for instance).
It is a great movie. It’s remarkable how the unspeakable horror of the trench war has inspired only the little few to express it, and especially in literature, I find, but in such cases so pathetically and vividly (Celine’s “Journey to the end of the night” for instance, or Blaise Cendrars’ “The Cut hand”). And there’s much less historical accounts on it also compared to what was published on WW2. As if the men who had seen it were hardly able to even talk about it…
There are the great English poets of world war one of course (Wilfred Owen, Isaac Rosenberg, Siegfried Sassoon, Edward Thomas, Rupert Brook, Robert Graves etc) - and many fine novels including Pat Baker's powerful Regeneration trilogy. (Will check out the Cendrars' poem - thanks)
Fracture (2007)
I saw this on tv last night; the story is great for a film, or would be if it let the killer go loose, just to rub it in. The film is let down by another truly dismal performance from Ryan Gosling, so laid back he falls over his eyelashes, and someone should have told him to stop using his hands in so melodramatic a fashion in the trial scene. What his reputation is based on I do not know. I am not sure if Anthony Hopkins has left Hannibal Lecter behind, his 'evil' persona is by now repetitive and boring. And why a Maori actor is pretending to be American I don't know, his accent was wooden. Major disappointment.
Fracture (2007) on DVD - Anthony Hopkins, Ryan Gosling - YouTube
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dL0lNGXoP8E
From Gaspar Noe, who did Irreversible, one of my other favorite flicks.