on-topic: which punisher do yathink was better?

[TheOne1]

http://www.soundtrackcollector.com/images/movie/large/Punisher_movie_poster.jpg <-- Sho'nuff

http://www.punisher-movie.com/images/pictures/movie/large/62.jpg

[STEVEJOHNSON]

i DON'T UNDERSTAND???

[TheOne1]

SORRY. WHICH PUNISHER MOVIE YA THINK IS BETTER... THE ONE IN THE FIRST PICTURE... OR THE ONE BELOW IT.

[JohnnyWalkerBlackLabel]

the 2nd Punisher movie was MUCH BETTER

[stillies77]

If Dolph acted like he did in Universal Soldier he would have blown tom jane out of the water...but Tom jane crushes him just for his fight with The Russian alone.

[bigpapa03]

thomas jane pulled out of punisher 2 so know they gotta recast

[DonPA]

Tom Jane is definitely a lot better than Dolph, but Stillies is almost right. It would be a lot tougher to decide if Dolph would have been like he was in Universal Soldier. It sucks Tom Jane pulled out of the project, but I fully understand his reasoning. Punisher 2 is going to suck without him.

[horny4sum]

I try not to think of the Dolph movie as really being a Punisher movie...it sucked horribly. So I guess you know what my answer is; and yes if they make the 2nd one without Jane it will suck too I'm sure.

[s-fme]

Number two with out a doubt, it stuck to the comic (in feel less than to the script). Tom Jane was so much better than Lundgren! As well, the supporting cast was much better in the second movie!