Is Madison Montag a Transsexual?

[TSLexiWade]

All i can say is she is a sweet girl and to the other ladys yeah she may talk bs online but ive seen many ppl talk bs on her.I just did America's next top tranny with her and she was sweet to me.

She was sweet to Ashley George too..


LOOOOKOUT!

[Birgitta]

Makes sense.

Not really, if i hear tlovers wanting to love me for my handicap while they have the simplistic mindset like that of feeders and amputeelovers...
And it does not make sense that people claim im backwards for being a girl, instead i should be masculine and serve them as a male sexually lol
And it does not make sense when i look around me and see that most tswoman appear to have a male ego, and are competing with eachother through looks...
I dont see any female uncertainty here

But well, im no ts indeed

[TSPornFan]

What do transsexuals do in countries where hormones or surgery aren't available?

A transsexual is not defined by what you do with your body - it's how you feel in yourself and how you identify yourself.

I think this post is pretty insulting and low class, to call out one specific model or individual. You could have created the question by just asking if a model who hasn't taken hormones, or surgery, is a trannssexual. POOR!!!

This topic was not made to be a personal attack. I did not lay judgement on her. I never said that she wasn't a transsexual. I asked this question for the members to voice their opinions.

Why are do people get pissed when a model is called out? Paying consumers have the right to call out a girl, praise a girl, and criticize a girl. It's no different than movie actors and sports stars. They get called out all of the time for their work. A pornstar's job is to be sexually appealing to consumers. Models SHOULD be open to criticism, but so many are extremely up tight.

No one has problems when someone praises a girl, but members start to complain when someone calls out someone or criticizes a girl.

I did not say models in general because I I don't know any other popular models who live without hormones and surgery.

It's Madison's body and it is her choice. I'm not saying she needs to get all of these things.

However, I can understand both sides of the argument. It is understandable for people to see her as a transsexual because she lives her life as a woman. It is also understandable for people to not see her as a transsexual because she has not done anything to have a feminine body.

I saw that you voted no.

[onmyknees]

Why let the girls decided Prospero? Nobody has the right to decide apart from the individual. Otherwise, we get damaged individuals like Paris having to justify their own existence by displacing her issues on others.

Absolutely !!!!!!!!! We go through this exercise almost weekly here in one form or another. It's entirely useless...interesting when the discussion is civil, but useless. I think this noses out the "Am I Gay If....." threads by a hair.
Let's lay it out there and be honest....some ladies on here that have achieved some level of success both in their transition, and their careers are the harshest critics of those who have fallen short of that mark, for whatever the reason. When issues concerning the LGBT arise, many are always lecturing us ( and rightfully so) about the merits of acceptance and tolerance. It usually center on their trials and tribulations during transition, and I can deeply appreciate .....not understand, but appreciate. But ironically they don't have much tolerance in this situation....So perhaps we should form a committee to do the decision making similar to what Congress has done in the Debt agreement. They could ultimately decide who gets the coveted crown of Transsexual and who still needs more work.... Absurd isn't it.....but no less absurd than these constant questions about whom is and who isn't.

Until such time....I'll be guided by my visual stimulus to whoever I find attractive and sexy, and I'm happy to let the rest of you all put a tag on her, or categorize her. I can't be bothered.
I'm inclined to agree with Steven on this ...."A transsexual is not defined by what you do with your body - it's how you feel in yourself and how you identify yourself." .........It occurs to me that in the end, they don't have to meet "The Paris Criteria" , as long as they meet their own ...Just MHO.

OK Paris...that's your que to call us cockhounds....(drumroll)......

[GroobySteven]

This topic was not made to be a personal attack. I did not lay judgement on her. I never said that she wasn't a transsexual. I asked this question for the members to voice their opinions.

Why are do people get pissed when a model is called out? Paying consumers have the right to call out a girl, praise a girl, and criticize a girl. It's no different than movie actors and sports stars. They get called out all of the time for their work. A pornstar's job is to be sexually appealing to consumers. Models SHOULD be open to criticism, but so many are extremely up tight.

No one has problems when someone praises a girl, but members start to complain when someone calls out someone or criticizes a girl.

I did not say models in general because I I don't know any other popular models who live without hormones and surgery.

It's Madison's body and it is her choice. I'm not saying she needs to get all of these things.

However, I can understand both sides of the argument. It is understandable for people to see her as a transsexual because she lives her life as a woman. It is also understandable for people to not see her as a transsexual because she has not done anything to have a feminine body.

I saw that you voted no.

But you could have done it without mentioning names? You are not calling her out as a transsexual pornstar - but just as a transsexual - if you were criticizing her on her roles, that would be different.

I voted YES - I think someone is playing funny buggers because I'm fairly sure some of those other voters would have put YES also.
Mods?

[TSPornFan]

But you could have done it without mentioning names? You are not calling her out as a transsexual pornstar - but just as a transsexual - if you were criticizing her on her roles, that would be different.

I voted YES - I think someone is playing funny buggers because I'm fairly sure some of those other voters would have put YES also.
Mods?

I'm calling her out as a transsexual pornstar. I thought I made it clear in the OP when I only mention Transsexual pornstars. I should had made myself more clear in the topic title and poll.

Sorry for being unclear.

[GroobySteven]

I'm calling her out as a transsexual pornstar. I thought I made it clear in the OP when I only mention Transsexual pornstars. I should had made myself more clear in the topic title and poll.

Sorry for being unclear.

Then that is a completely different kettle of fish as it could be more determined by the consumer, than anything else.

[Nikka]

No such thing, a true transsexual risks it all.

first time I don´t agree with you Paris

[Bobby Domino]

Being a TG is a state of mind, no? If Madison considers herself a TG then we can't really argue with that, hormones/surgery or no hormones/surgery. She could feel comfortable enough where she feels she doesn't need any physical enhancements, or simply hasn't started her transition. Nonetheless when I was looking at her pics recently, I wondered if her "look" was any different than a fem boi. Don't care really, I think she's cute...

[SirCumsAlot]

What do transsexuals do in countries where hormones or surgery aren't available?

A transsexual is not defined by what you do with your body - it's how you feel in yourself and how you identify yourself.

I think this post is pretty insulting and low class, to call out one specific model or individual. You could have created the question by just asking if a model who hasn't taken hormones, or surgery, is a trannssexual. POOR!!!

What I think what the OP meant was is it possible for there to be a genetically born TS, I guess with already with two sex organs, such as in certain species of animals that are born both male and females, such as snails, certain fishes, and whchever other animals I missed. I think he meant Madison meant that she was born with the two sexes, maybe with the two sex organs, the obvious male organ and natural boobs. I dont know though, that was my assumption from the op as Im just waking up from a very long sleep.

I remember way back when I first started getting into TS porn, there was a model I found who claimed she was naturally born as and with both male and female organs; that she naturally had a penis, and her boobs were natural as well from birth (claim she needed no hormones nor implants/surgeries). I can't remember her name. All I remember is that she is mixed with egyptian and her name started with a S. She did, maybe still do, had her own website. I think she was primarily an escort than a pornstar.