Results 1 to 10 of 14
Thread: Court grants teen breast removal
-
05-05-2009 #1
- Join Date
- Oct 2007
- Posts
- 2,207
Court grants teen breast removal
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/asi...ic/8032172.stm
An Australian teenage girl has been given permission by a court to have both breasts surgically removed to more closely resemble a boy.
The 17-year-old, known as Alex in court and referred to as a boy, has a psychological condition that makes him unhappy with his gender.
The Family Court in Melbourne said the removal of both breasts would help Alex to build a new life as a boy.
The decision has angered Catholic groups, who view it as irresponsible.
Alex has "gender identity dysphoria", a psychological condition where a person believes they are the opposite sex, the Age newspaper reported.
Alex has been on hormone treatment since he was 13 to prevent menstruation, it said.
Social development
He applied to the court for a double mastectomy before he turned 18 - the age at which he would not need the court's consent and which he would no longer receive social support services as a minor.
Family Court chief justice Diana Bryant said Alex, who lives life as a male, was socially constrained by the breasts, avoided being hugged and wore binding at the beach.
"So it was quite an impediment to his social development, which everyone thought was very important," Judge Bryant was quoted as saying by the Age.
"Overwhelmingly, the evidence was that it was in his interests. And I made that order.
"I wanted to make it quickly so that he could have the operation straight away.''
Critics say that such radical surgery on a 17-year-old is irresponsible and premature.
Campaigners have said that a man from Melbourne who had a sex-change operation in his early 20s was now suing his doctors because he regretted the decision.
-
05-05-2009 #2
Re: Court grants teen breast removal
Originally Posted by JamesHunt
IDK what kind of screening FtMs are put threw, but GGs wanting smaller breasts (because of sagging problems or back problems, etc) often don't need much more than a single 45 min screening before getting the ok, even if they're minors.
And maybe its easier to withdraw from life
With all of its misery and wretched lies
If we're dead when tomorrow's gone
The Big Machine will just move on
Still we cling afraid we'll fall
Clinging like the memory which haunts us all
-
05-05-2009 #3
- Join Date
- Nov 2007
- Posts
- 95
Re: Court grants teen breast removal
Originally Posted by JamesHunt
-
05-05-2009 #4
Wow what a beautiful story - there is hope in man kind when I read such beautiful stories like these as opposed to daily media.
Thanks for sharing it
Originally Posted by jcinva
-
05-05-2009 #5
Re: Court grants teen breast removal
Originally Posted by timebomb
Some doctors are artists and will tell you - Nope, you are done. The doctors who do this kind of work see the body as the artist sees the canvas.
That is how I see my body. It was a blank canvas into which with numerous painful procedures now has the color and earn the name painting.
We are not just mentally disabled. With good guidance some of us actually turn out better individuals then those who promote hate. Hate in other's beliefs is what I call " a living hell ".
When I was 16 my emotional mind was already developed. I knew I was different. I am glad it lead me to this day and I am blessed to have this life.
Originally Posted by jcinva
-
05-05-2009 #6
He better merry a TS.
Originally Posted by tjinla2001
I AM A GUY NOT A TRANSSEXUAL!
I AM A GUY NOT A TRANSSEXUAL!
-
05-05-2009 #7
- Join Date
- Jan 2008
- Posts
- 6,100
i hope this infuriated the haters.
he's not stepping on anyones toes. just doing him. STFU
-
05-05-2009 #8
- Join Date
- Jan 2008
- Location
- Australia
- Posts
- 238
Re: Court grants teen breast removal
Originally Posted by SarahG
-
05-05-2009 #9
Re: Court grants teen breast removal
Originally Posted by Danielle Foxx
And maybe its easier to withdraw from life
With all of its misery and wretched lies
If we're dead when tomorrow's gone
The Big Machine will just move on
Still we cling afraid we'll fall
Clinging like the memory which haunts us all
-
05-05-2009 #10
- Join Date
- Apr 2007
- Posts
- 1,245
Glad to hear progress is being made in Australia. Let's hope it keeps on moving forward in the rest of the world.