Results 11 to 20 of 45
Thread: Do you believe in Equality?
-
01-09-2008 #11
Re: Do you believe in Equality?
Originally Posted by DJ_Asia
-
01-09-2008 #12
- Join Date
- Dec 2007
- Location
- Georgia
- Posts
- 136
Well Falrune I stand corrected but I think my interpretation still holds true. They put in a new policy once they realized that they were going to have a large influx of Asians if AA was removed. A lot of Whites were under the impression that it would help them but it wasn't nearly as beneficial as they thought it would be. My thing is you want it based solely on merit then do so but don't turn around and come up with a "new" policy to make it closer to the way it was. That was all about politics. The school's demographics wouldn't have reflected the state population. They realized the potential backlash of not instituting a new policy. If Cali had been 80% Asian I don't thinking anyone would've made a peep. The politicians getaway with playing both sides. They can say they killed AA but fixed the demographic problem.
-
01-09-2008 #13
Re: Do you believe in Equality?
Originally Posted by Falrune
Freedom of Speech? Ask the "Dont Tase Me Bro" guy about that right.
Right to vote?Sure you can vote,but ask Diebold and Al Gore about that right...
Right to Privacy? Ask the authors & supporters of the Patriot Act about the 4th amendment.
I could go on but my point is clear...AmeriKKKa doesnt come close to delivering what the founding fathers promised so many years ago.
I have so much more respect for a nation that may not deliver many rights but at least they are honest about it.
-
01-09-2008 #14Originally Posted by ShadowMaster
-
01-09-2008 #15
All men are created equal" was meant to be taken in the context of Justice. I do believe, very strongly(since I spent 26 years fighting for your rights) that everyone regardless of race, color, creed should be treated equally, according to the law, without bias.
People, themselves, however.....Are not equal, and never will be. That is why, as a benevalent society, it is incumbent on those with the means, to provide a little assistance to those not so fortunate. We are, in effect, our brothers keeper.
-
01-09-2008 #16Originally Posted by CORVETTEDUDE
People, themselves, however.....Are not equal, and never will be. That is why, as a benevolent society, it is incumbent on those with the means, to provide a little assistance to those not so fortunate. We are, in effect, our brothers keeper.
-
01-09-2008 #17
I don't think equality is possible within a free-market capitalist society.
I don't think equality is possible when speaking about things like ability or intelligence.
I do think it is possible to rectify egregious historical inequities.
Here you speak of Affirmative Action, but not of genocide, slavery, colonization, and its legacy of poverty, war, and disease.
Whether equality is possible is a little besides the point. The legacy of colonialism and slavery needs to be addressed.
-
01-09-2008 #18Originally Posted by ShadowMaster
Secondary education is unequal as far as opportunities go, college is generally expensive stuff and if you're in the poorest SEC you're not gonna be able to afford to send your kid there even with all the financial aid packages around unless you either take a gamble and burden the kid with loans, or give the school such a sob story that they feel sorry for you and give it away. Even then its not a sure bet, if you're in the lowest SEC you're generally not even making even, the stats show this SEC makes a -1% of the distribution of national income annually. So what about all the costs that even generous schools can't cover?
Sure, we could make secondary complusitory and make it so any random person in the world could afford it; but then the quality of the education decreases, its value decreases and atstead of actually fixing anything; now everyone needs to go to graduate school to make what a 2-yr or 4-yr would have given them in employment earning statistics.
However all systems are inherently flawed because they're created and run by people. Life is inherently unfair. But what keeps you down may bring you up in different situation.
no one is going to knowingly allow you to drive the car in to a ditch without a fight.
And maybe its easier to withdraw from life
With all of its misery and wretched lies
If we're dead when tomorrow's gone
The Big Machine will just move on
Still we cling afraid we'll fall
Clinging like the memory which haunts us all
-
01-09-2008 #19
Richard Dawkins discusses at some length in The God Delusion the evolutionary force of inequality: that is, that it is beneficial to the survival of the group (and thus of the species) to favor the members of your group and oppose the members of other groups. Over time, this progressed from tribal to city-state to regional to national groups, and there has been a general (and significant) trend towards greater equality (of rights, not of ability or intelligence, as Mandy points out) for all people. We're still a long way from achieving true equality, but consider our progress with a few key notes:
The Magna Carta: the beginnings of modern liberty, though at the time for the noblity only, diminishing the power of the king.
The Amercian Declaration of Independence: "these truths are self-evident, that all men are created equal, and are endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable rights, among these Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness" (emphasis mine). Note the this speaks of MEN: not women. And, in fact, in the cultural climate of the 17th century, Blacks and other minorities were not accepted as "men."
Emancipation Proclamation: freeing the slaves in America (see comments above regarding the negatives that followed this, but it was a major step forward).
Women's Suffrage: Beginning in New Zealand in 1898, and then through Canada, the US, GB, and other industrialized nations over the next half century, women gained the right to vote.
Of course, there's more, and there are failings aplenty. But in general, the trend is towards equality, and perhaps in some distant future century we'll actually acheive equality.
-
01-09-2008 #20
- Join Date
- Mar 2006
- Location
- The United Fuckin' States of America
- Posts
- 13,898
Justice is the attempt to establish equality. The angle by which the proverbial playing field is tilted measures how unjust the game.
"...I no longer believe that people's secrets are defined and communicable, or their feelings full-blown and easy to recognize."_Alice Munro, Chaddeleys and Flemings.
"...the order in creation which you see is that which you have put there, like a string in a maze, so that you shall not lose your way". _Judge Holden, Cormac McCarthy's, BLOOD MERIDIAN.