PDA

View Full Version : Shemale-Gate



EvaCassini
12-12-2014, 11:26 PM
Hi, I am Eva Cassini Stark, and I am a "shemale".
I wrote this in response to this situation I have been following closely between the TG Porn Industry and a select few who plan to bring about "change". This select few, but particularly, one individual, does not understand the grasp of the situation as a whole. To learn more about "this" in particular, I suggest reading Steven's latest blog post about the word "Shemale".
http://grooby.com/groobysteven/uncategorized/shemale-shemale.html


Here is my view on it. A bit long, but informative. I stand with Steven of Grooby, and Bob of Bob's Tgirls.

As a free thinking, pro-science transgender girl, as someone in the trans community, and as someone who is in the adult film industry, I find it absolutely silly and ridiculous to get offended by words.

Shemale, tranny, transgender, transsexual, trans, tg, ts, are all terms that have described me and the rest of the transgirls and transguys in the community and the industry for years. I, and many others, do NOT take offense to these words. What I personally take offense to is being labeled/called something I am not. Like for instance, I am not a transvestite/crossdresser/TV.

Transvestite/Crossdresser/TV - All of which mean, one who dons the clothing of the opposite sex for mainly sexual pleasure, as a fetish or a lifestyle. These words in them of themselves are NOT offensive. They merely describe. Transvestite or "Transvestit", from Latin trans- ‘across’ + vestire 'clothe', dates back to the 1700s. Crossdresser is much more recent, but is simply translates from the word "Transvestite" and is used as it's synonym. TV is simply an abbreviation of TransVestite.

Just as "TG" is short for Transgender. Just as "Tranny" is a playful short synonym for Transgender/sexual.
I honestly do not want a "new term" that only we can use or for use of education. It would be ridiculous and redundant, as we already have words to describe us. We have "Transgender", we have "transsexual", we have their abbreviations "TG" and "TS", and we have "Shemale", "Tranny", "Transgirl" and "Transman". Those work just fine and are not offensive at all.


The ONLY people I KNOW who get offended by these words, are people who are NOT them, and a select few who are, whose only plan is to bring attention to themselves by means of a ploy constructed by this so-called arbiter, who is using their campaign to stop the use of these words, only to market themselves and sell their DVD. Everyone is so scared to offend with words, and they shouldn't be afraid. They are ONLY words and words are ONLY a mix of sounds uttered from our mouths to come together to communicate and describe the universe and all in it.

What is there to gain for being offended by words? Absolutely nothing.
What helps the community realistically, are actions.

When one allows words or labels to control them, then that person loses a sense of self.

My quality, actions, personality, work ethic, honor, and how I treat people define me. Labels, names, terms, and such like Tranny, Shemale, Trans(whatever), Ladyboy*, TS, and TG are ONLY words to describe, and if you give them power, they will overpower you. One shouldn't let words control who they are. Life is way too short to have anger, disdain, and despondency for words.

The only words that would offend me, and many transfolk who I know (in and out of the adult industry), would be words that incorrectly describe and define me. Words of which that contradict who and what I am.

I am Eva Cassini Stark. Correct.

I am in transition. Correct.

I have both male and female sexual characteristics. Correct.

Being that I am in transition of my physical body from male to female (gender/sex), I must be a transgender/transsexual. Correct.

Tranny is a shortening of Trans(gender/sexual), which has no degree of hate in it of itself. Correct.

The only way for it and other aforementioned words to be used in a hateful manner would be to spout it out with hateful and harmful intentions and actions. Correct.

Shemale is not a shortening, nor is it really a synonym. There is Male. There is Female. Females are referred to as "She", a pronoun to describe a female in simple present tense.

The "wo" and "fe" in woman and female, respectively, delegate a distinction between man/male and woman/female. So using "She" in front of male to create the word "Shemale", really is the exact same thing as Female. It is a slang to describe a transgirl. And it's a great marketing word to distinguish the TG porn from GG porn (GG- abbreviated porn slang for genetic girl (female)). There is no negativity in it unless it is used in a hateful and harmful way. And even still, would you prosecute the word uttered or the hateful person's actions that coincide, only by happenstance, with using the word? I vote the latter!


*Ladyboy is a word I don't typically use to describe myself, as I am opposed to the boy portion. But in the Indian dialect of Kuwi, boy actually means girl. So with that simple fact about Lady-"boy", one must understand that language is ONLY sounds that we utter out of our mouths; and albeit words and language are fun and interesting, words, names, and language really do not matter.


"Eva Cassini Stark" and my interaction with others identify me.
When I am out in public and I mingle with people, I tell them I am transgendered and if they don't understand that, I will use "Shemale". They react with awe and tell me they never would have guessed. That or they are fans of mine. So they already know.

Those who get hung up way too harshly on words bring hardship onto themselves. Fighting a "Word War" is frivolous and ridiculous.

Here's a "hypothetical". Just because someone would have to call you a female or whatever you prefer, due to a hypothetical political correctness law, it still would NOT negate that person's hate, disgust, and distrust for transfolk. It would be like wearing a facade. They would be lying to you and themselves.

Words carry no weight.
Actions do. Specifically, positive and ethically right actions. Having "Integrity".

When people show initiative to bring enlightenment to those who do not understand what it is to be transgender, THAT is what will help us. Not fighting against words.

Imagine...If there was a day of the year, mandated by law, in which EVERYONE was not permitted to speak any words and would not be able to write anything, under penalty of death. No communication of any kind at all, except for gestures.
Do you honestly believe the hate will stop? I sincerely implore you to think hard about that, as the hate will not cease. Only in a fairy-tale or Disney movies would this work.


I have no intentions of belittling what those who came before me did. I do not mean any disrespect. They have shed some light on transfolk but not at all enough. Still today, there are many misconceptions about transfolk and also an abundance of hate, disgust, and distrust toward us. On television, we are jokes. Across the country, there are still horrible hate crimes committed against transfolk. Around the world, there are countries where one would face bludgeoning, imprisonment, and/or even death, if it was uncovered that they were in fact trans. We are very far from being treated with respect as anyone else who isn't trans.

Grooby (Steven at the forefront) and it's affiliates ( PORN companies, for dick-sakes!), have taken long and hard strides to help the trans community. Yes, they make "Shemale" and "Trannydude" Porn, BUT, that does take away from their positive moral goal to bring about peace and understanding to all, to help transfolk. I speak for Grooby and their affiliates, only because they have treated me with respect, courtesy, and shown great generosity.

Fighting against words will not get us where we want to be. Actions will. These folks with their plight with words is folly. Put that energy to better use and go out and speak up for us. Educate what and who we are. I have a platform that I have built WITH the help of Grooby and it's affiliates, which allows me to reach lots of people. Any chance I get, and there are many, I try to educate and help others understand us.

I simply implore anyone to see what and where our true battles lie. Which is why one should not focus on words, but focus on actions of those for and against us and the science of trans, to help make our society more accepting and respectful towards transfolk.

Tara Emory
12-12-2014, 11:54 PM
Yeah, if you read her article she even says that "TS" is a hurtful term. When a TS has a problem being called a TS, then trans activism has jumped the shark.

Basically she's saying "these are a list of words I want to ban', and then "this is a list of approved words" of which only seems to be "transwomen", which to me is a form of censorship.

Which, of course someone will have a hissy fit in a few years about it containing the suffix "men", so we'll all have to call ourselves "transwomyn".

I wrote a big tumblr post about this. It's not really that I disagree with Chelsea Poe, it just looks like someone looking for attention, and also that she's a transphobic transperson, who abhors the idea of being lumped in the same category as anything else in the trans spectrum that ISN'T a tgirl who got hormones when she was 18 and is horrified that any of use would enjoy using our penises. I roll my eyes when I see activism like this and it's like people trying to enforce rigid militant recycling, but they're doing it in New Orleans right after Hurricane Katrina....

The people murdering us every 36 hours (a statistic I have no idea where that came from) aren't calling us trannies or shemales, they're calling us guys and dudes and shaming us for ever being boys in the first place. People who accept trans folk know (and need to accept) that we once had other lives and lived as other genders. I have come to terms with this myself and once you accept all the things that make you unique, wether thats having boobs and a cock, or being a silly pervert, then really, words can't harm you.


My tumblr post is here: http://taraemory.tumblr.com/post/104755841353/to-all-the-young-naive-trans-activists-out-there

I'm going to write something a bit nicer though, because I'm otherwise in agreement with about 90% of what Chelsea Poe says. It's just the last 10% of it that I can't get on board with.

-Tara

wikid0ne
12-13-2014, 12:13 AM
great read

lordworm
12-13-2014, 12:15 AM
I agree, political correctness is absurd. I love me some shemales.

christianxxx
12-13-2014, 02:20 AM
excellent post Tara! well done

TempestTS
12-13-2014, 03:11 AM
its a simple realization,,, Words cant beat you...

I couldnt be anybody other than who I am if I tried... so I'll be over here not giving a fuck

Ecstatic
12-13-2014, 06:12 PM
Great post, Eva. Really nothing to add except "what she said."

crystalsopen
12-14-2014, 05:04 AM
Yeah, if you read her article she even says that "TS" is a hurtful term. When a TS has a problem being called a TS, then trans activism has jumped the shark.

Basically she's saying "these are a list of words I want to ban', and then "this is a list of approved words" of which only seems to be "transwomen", which to me is a form of censorship.

Which, of course someone will have a hissy fit in a few years about it containing the suffix "men", so we'll all have to call ourselves "transwomyn".

I wrote a big tumblr post about this. It's not really that I disagree with Chelsea Poe, it just looks like someone looking for attention, and also that she's a transphobic transperson, who abhors the idea of being lumped in the same category as anything else in the trans spectrum that ISN'T a tgirl who got hormones when she was 18 and is horrified that any of use would enjoy using our penises. I roll my eyes when I see activism like this and it's like people trying to enforce rigid militant recycling, but they're doing it in New Orleans right after Hurricane Katrina....

The people murdering us every 36 hours (a statistic I have no idea where that came from) aren't calling us trannies or shemales, they're calling us guys and dudes and shaming us for ever being boys in the first place. People who accept trans folk know (and need to accept) that we once had other lives and lived as other genders. I have come to terms with this myself and once you accept all the things that make you unique, wether thats having boobs and a cock, or being a silly pervert, then really, words can't harm you.


My tumblr post is here: http://taraemory.tumblr.com/post/104755841353/to-all-the-young-naive-trans-activists-out-there

I'm going to write something a bit nicer though, because I'm otherwise in agreement with about 90% of what Chelsea Poe says. It's just the last 10% of it that I can't get on board with.

-Tara

Excellent post Tara! I would love to see her dedicate this much time and effort to workplace discrimination, housing discrimination, the groups that publicly shame trans kids for playing sports, the treatment of twoc by law enforcement, trans student housing discrimination or any of the other more serious issues trans people face in the US. Just my $0.02

CrystalKing
12-14-2014, 06:46 AM
Well said :)

(And in case anyone missed it, here's the original Chelsea Poe (http://www.xojane.com/sex/chelsea-poe-shemale-slur-petition) article in which she's advocating banning the word.)

Tara Emory
12-14-2014, 10:32 PM
Well, I finally wrote a blog post articulating why I'm not thrilled by the petition, You can read it here:

http://tara-ts.com/blog/?p=1830

-Tara

EvaCassini
12-14-2014, 10:40 PM
A wonderful read Tara!

Love it and I agree! Well spoken!

See you in Feb babe! <3

Tara Emory
12-14-2014, 11:00 PM
oh, and I fully admit I AM trying to further my career ambitions by posting my opinion and blowing out social media!

I've been doing what I do for 15 years, and it's high time I cashed in on all this!

-Tara

EvaCassini
12-14-2014, 11:23 PM
Hehehe. Nothing wrong there ;)

Tara Emory
12-15-2014, 12:23 AM
Arguing with Chelsea Poe on twitter is like arguing with a brick wall.

EvaCassini
12-15-2014, 01:31 AM
LOL yeah, that's why I won't because I know what kind of person she is.

About 10 minutes ago, she saw I favorite'd your tweets, and she tweeted me to chat with her via email. I don't feel like chatting.

lilmunat
12-15-2014, 02:24 AM
Well, I finally wrote a blog post articulating why I'm not thrilled by the petition, You can read it here:

http://tara-ts.com/blog/?p=1830

-Tara

Tara, I love your work. I stopped reading your opinion piece once I read, "Do I care what you think? Not really".

Why do you think I should care about your opinion if you aren't willing to give me the same courtesy?

EvaCassini
12-15-2014, 02:35 AM
In all honesty, I would implore you to read her whole piece. Otherwise you are taking this way out of context. You should read the entire thing before getting offended at the first thing that one could take out of context.

Tara Emory
12-15-2014, 03:20 AM
yeah, i just spent all day on twitter with her and a few others, agreeing about certain things, disagreeing about a lot of things.

I think it really came to a head when i said that I had endured far far far worse things said to me and i survived, and them saying that's not an arguement in favor of these "slurs" being used.

I tried to tell them that there's is always going to be something worse, something else out there. it doesn't mean not to fight for what you believe in, and it's not defeatist.

Remember the 1990's? We tore down the Berlin Wall and that fixed everything, right? decades earlier, hippies put flowers in guns during Vietnam protests and after that there was never ever another war, right? Of course not.

Part of what I'm trying to say is that there's always going to be discrimination out there and always going to be people who are going to say the worst things and do the worst things to us. I even thought a number of years back that we were going to have more equality and understanding between the sexes, as soon as you think of that, Men's Rights activists rear their ugly head.

The civil rights movement fixed racism forever, right? As we're seeing now, it didnt. Will racism ever be erased? I have no idea. It doesn't mean we shouldn't fight for it though, but guess what, there will be an equal number of people fighting to KEEP the system the way it is.

Oh yeah, global warming, we fixed that too, right? Back when we all decided to stop driving cars and emitting noxious fumes into the atmosphere. Oh wait that didn't happen, and guess what, I wouldn't invest in any waterfront property any time, well. ever.


Somewhere in your late 20s your idealism evaporates and you figure out which battles are worth fighting and which ones aren't. When you get older you actually come to the realization that the human race is a bunch of parasites, and that people are really horrible. The idealism of the 90's went up in smoke on 9/11

Are we making a better world for ourselves? I hope so. Am I still trying for that better world? Yes, in my own way.

And I guess this is why I cant get myself worked up over two freaking letters at the end of an established word. I got accused of "victim blamimg" and I'm not sure how to even respond to that.

Tara

christianxxx
12-15-2014, 03:37 AM
her campaign is 100 percent rooted in the thought process of trying to sell more DVD's of Fucking Mystic. everything else related to that is just gravy to her. Marketing Genius really. Unfortunately no one buys DVD's anymore lol

EvaCassini
12-15-2014, 03:57 AM
Well spoken, once again Tara! We should def high five in Feb! Maybe hug too...and stuff :D

And Christian, HAHAHA nail in the head! Good one.

Michelle Firestone
12-15-2014, 04:18 AM
Arguing with Chelsea Poe on twitter is like arguing with a brick wall.

More like banging your head against it.

lifeisfiction
12-15-2014, 04:20 AM
Can someone tell me why Chelsea Poe is using the word queer where a lot of people in the gay the community finds it offensive?

EvaCassini
12-15-2014, 05:14 AM
We are wondering that too.

That is another reason why I use the word hypocrite when speaking about CP.

Tara Emory
12-15-2014, 11:22 PM
Well. I also wrote a blog post about what I LIKE about her viewpoints, and that's important too.

Life gets complicated when you see both sides on an issue. This situation gets complicated when trans folk cite articles written by progressive cis people saying that these words are slurs, and here i am, trans, saying wtf? It's not your place to tell me which words are slurs.

Im all for using whatever words we want to use. And the trans porn producers are in their own way, bigger trans allies than when overly politicallu correct people who probably hate all porn start to tell me I can't say "tranny"

But there's something else I took out of this, and it's not really the crux of her argument but it's something about her career choices that I do like. I can't vouch for the quality of the content of "Fucking Mystic", but I can applaud it for not having a trans-identifier in the title. I'm all for blowing the doors of creativity wide open by saying that we don't have to use ANY trans terms if we don't want to.

It's just a matter of seeing wether the market will accept that or not.

anyway, i wrote a bit about what I like about her viewpoints, even if I disagree with a lot of it.

http://tara-ts.com/blog/?p=1838

-tara