PDA

View Full Version : 2nd round knockout competition should it be seeded ? and other ways to improve ?



gjamestgirlfan
06-03-2010, 05:52 PM
The 1st round will soon be coming to a end,

on 2nd round info eg should there be seedings for the girls ? eg girls who win group avoid eachother in next round, or keep same. as fun of is not knowing who get into the next round, this is what this poll is for, the one with the most votes i will do for the 2nd round, i quite like the randomness for not knowing what groups will be and the favourites will always get through, but nice to see some different girls get through and maybe takes away the obvious results in each group.

also can i ask everyone for any improvements i can make to this 1st round, to improve the 2nd round ?

i think has gone quite well really, and people kept voting whole time, also do people think a month is 2 long to vote? as means when do last group have to wait 30 days until i can start the 2nd round.

I will be coming into the polls each day from 19th June when groups 1-8 finsh, giving the results of groups as done 4 a day apart from 2 days i think, so be interesting to see results.

Last question should i do wildcard positions as well, as everyone knew was 64 groups of 8 so 512 girls but i made mistakes on 6 girls SO FAR been repeated so one group has 6 girls, which the top girl will qualify from, then 4 other groups had 1 repeated girl so 7 in a group, so 2 will qualify.

I then from group 56 will be adding sometimes 9 girls in a group and 3 qualify for next round, i was wondering if i should also do wildcard positions eg the 5 best runners up or 3rd place girls with the most votes qualify as well for 2nd round (which will consist of 128 girls + extra group qualifications eg wildcard and 3 qualify via later groups.

pman618
06-03-2010, 07:06 PM
Few thoughts:

- I agree with wild card depending on how you determine the slots (you can't use number of votes because the first girls were receiving votes long before the last group)
- I would wait for brackets until down to a more manageable number

just some quick thoughts.

porschedan
06-03-2010, 08:30 PM
i think the brackets should stay random, also the polls could close a lot sooner, like maybe a week, because the replies to them die down quick

also you say the first round will come to an end soon, i havent seen some of my favourites yet and im hoping theyre in it cause theyre a lot more popular and deserving than some girls posted

girls i don't recall seeing yet:
Mickelly Miranda
Kalena Rios
Sasha Hevyn
Mylena Bismark
Larissa Monteiro
Maryann
Karolina Gaucha
Joy Spears
Juliana Araujo
Wanessa Waitzel
milena Santos
Danika Dreamz

bulldog
06-03-2010, 08:35 PM
i think the brackets should stay random, also the polls could close a lot sooner, like maybe a week, because the replies to them die down quick

also you say the first round will come to an end soon, i havent seen some of my favourites yet and im hoping theyre in it cause theyre a lot more popular and deserving than some girls posted

girls i don't recall seeing yet:
Mickelly Miranda
Kalena Rios
Sasha Hevyn
Mylena Bismark
Larissa Monteiro
Maryann
Karolina Gaucha
Joy Spears
Juliana Araujo
Wanessa Waitzel
Milena Santos


If that Maryann is the one I am thinking of, she is downright gorgeous

porschedan
06-03-2010, 08:39 PM
this Maryann

http://pic.aebn.net/Stream/Movie/Boxcovers/a57652_xlf.jpg

TGL
06-03-2010, 09:14 PM
I think seedings would be a good idea, to be more certain that it is the girls that the board prefers who actually goes through to the next round. If a lot of winners end up in one poll and a lot of "runners up" end in another poll, there might be girls who proceed from the runners up category, who wouldn't have proceeded if they were placed in a seeded poll. That's the way I think it should be.

Otherwise, great work! And no matter how you arrange the 2nd round, I'll vote in every single poll for sure! This is a super iniative!

pman618
06-03-2010, 09:16 PM
What about Mariana Cordoba? Haven't seen her yet.

porschedan
06-03-2010, 09:55 PM
What about Mariana Cordoba? Haven't seen her yet.

she was in group 3 and is winning it easily

TGL
06-03-2010, 10:01 PM
I must say I miss Kalena Rios too btw.! She is a super hottie and she simply needs to be in this, please!

Star Angel 86
06-03-2010, 10:20 PM
i think the brackets should stay random, also the polls could close a lot sooner, like maybe a week, because the replies to them die down quick

also you say the first round will come to an end soon, i havent seen some of my favourites yet and im hoping theyre in it cause theyre a lot more popular and deserving than some girls posted

girls i don't recall seeing yet:
Mickelly Miranda
Kalena Rios
Sasha Hevyn
Mylena Bismark
Larissa Monteiro
Maryann
Karolina Gaucha
Joy Spears
Juliana Araujo
Wanessa Waitzel
milena Santos
Danika Dreamz

I voted for Mylena Bismark,I can't remember which round though.

partlycloudy
06-03-2010, 10:28 PM
*keep it random
*shorter polls
*no wildcard

if a girl can't win her group then she doesn't deserve to move on.
there can only be 1 winner in the end anyway.

gjamestgirlfan
06-03-2010, 10:31 PM
i think the brackets should stay random, also the polls could close a lot sooner, like maybe a week, because the replies to them die down quick

also you say the first round will come to an end soon, i havent seen some of my favourites yet and im hoping theyre in it cause theyre a lot more popular and deserving than some girls posted

girls i don't recall seeing yet:
Mickelly Miranda - There is a Mickelly in group 45, is that her ?
Kalena Rios
Sasha Hevyn
Mylena Bismark
Larissa Monteiro
Maryann
Karolina Gaucha
Joy Spears
Juliana Araujo
Wanessa Waitzel
milena Santos
Danika Dreamz


Ok i was thinking that a month was too long, but be amazing how many votes still getting for group 1, i think in last 2 weeks have had another 70 votes, so its still going strong but i think that 2 weeks be plenty of time for it.
Thanks for comments on that, for 2nd round i will count, i was intending on doing the votes for wildcard at the end of a month for every group, so every group would have had the same amount of voting time.
So the 2nd round wont be starting for about a months time, or is that 2 long ?
Regarding the other girls feel free to put some pictures of them girls on here and i will check out if got enough space to add them into groups as i still need to add a few girls.
Thanks for comments
Gaz

gjamestgirlfan
06-03-2010, 10:32 PM
I think Mylena Bismark is in group 37 as well.

JimmyShushine
06-03-2010, 10:40 PM
First may I say, well done and congrats on a very well made and well run competition. It's an almost impossible task to get every girl in there, but as far as stunners go Keilana Love absolutely has got to be in there, in my opinion one of the finest girls in the world. I know there are still a few groups to go so I'm still hoping she'll be there, but just to remind you, here she is, please include her, please :)

gjamestgirlfan
06-03-2010, 10:47 PM
You got one to prove she is a transgender girl Jimmy, then i will make sure she is included for you as first one to post some pictures of her, she is a cutie.
Also thanks for compliments on how i have run this competition.

JimmyShushine
06-03-2010, 11:20 PM
Thanks GJames, I thought for the sake of the competition she definitely should be included and I think you are right to look for proof as I think whoever wins there should be photographic evidence of her being transgender ( cough, cough, Jen Paris, cough, cough ) :)

sucka4chix
06-03-2010, 11:20 PM
Few thoughts:

- I agree with wild card depending on how you determine the slots (you can't use number of votes because the first girls were receiving votes long before the last group)
- I would wait for brackets until down to a more manageable number

just some quick thoughts.

Polls were only open for a specific period of time

sucka4chix
06-03-2010, 11:26 PM
The competition is all ready tainted. It shoulda been seeded in the first round if at all. Some of the groups were so unfair with 3 or 4 top level girls and some groups with 8 girls that were questionable as to how they got in at all. At this point there are some great girls that are out, so why seed it now? It's not scientific so let all the grumbling and arguments begin--- that's gonna be half the fun.

porschedan
06-03-2010, 11:30 PM
no thats some other mickelly, this is Mickelly Miranda

http://shemalemodelindex.com/gallerydata/693_8.jpg
http://shemalemodelindex.com/gallerydata/702_8.jpg
http://shemalemodelindex.com/gallerydata/694_2.jpg
http://shemalemodelindex.com/gallerydata/377_0.jpg

gjamestgirlfan
06-04-2010, 12:06 AM
Oh ok thanks for comments, as i done the competition to show how many amazing transgender women out there, i have done 512 girls and i seriousally believe i could do another 512 girls.
I just thought was fair to keep it random as to give girls not quite so well known a chance, yes i was sad about some girls all being in same group but thats part of fun of it, i thought for the 2nd round i would give everyone a chance to vote for which they prefer.
Also Porschedan, please feel free to add pictures of the girls you would like to be in the competiton but be quick as they groups are running out quick, what i can do is put them in and not guareentee they will be in the groups as its all by chance, and girls already got lined up for competition but part of this is 2 listen to your voters and i would defo add the first girl you ask for, and then the others i will add into collection and see.
I know not all girls i included everyone taste but thats fun of it, isnt it, your comments here are really helping me, try and make this competition better.

pman618
06-04-2010, 12:20 AM
she was in group 3 and is winning it easily
Thanks! ......

porschedan
06-04-2010, 12:33 AM
Danika Dreamz
http://www.shemalecanada.com/escort/danika/danika8.jpg
http://new.groobybucks.com/thumbnails/1227722417/mpeg_escort_dicks_4.jpg
http://pic.leech.it/i/20f3a/f6ae2cbe15361danik.jpg
http://saucygalleries.com/galleries/2006/10/danika_shemale_yum_1006/danika_shemale_yum_1006_013.jpg

porschedan
06-04-2010, 12:39 AM
Kalena Rios

http://gallys.onlytgirls.com/pics/086-kalena_rios_1/pics/onlytgirls_com_kalena_rios_1-012.jpg
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_sbS9ko5hB4I/SVMtaA-ifWI/AAAAAAAAARs/Q2f2TU1nFGQ/s400/Calena_Rios_1.jpg
http://www.brasilianladyboy.com/wp-content/ladyboypics/kalena-rios1.jpg

gjamestgirlfan
06-04-2010, 02:04 AM
I thought i had put Kalena Rios that is a hot photo of her sitting on the football, very nice. I will add these girls into the possibility of being drawn into groups for 2mrw's 2.

jniowa
06-04-2010, 05:28 AM
Kalena does deserve to be in the mix but its understandable that with 512 girls, a few would slip through the cracks.

I do feel that there should be photographic evidence of the girls being transgendered. Just an opinion.

I'm looking forward to see how this plays out. Its been fun so far!!!

GullyFoyle
06-04-2010, 06:34 AM
This poll has been anything but fair. I can see your inherent bias towards your favorites by 1) the number of pictures for each (some girls have one and the ones you like have a dozen) and 2) whether or not they show their junk. Some people here think only of that so naturally the biggest, bushiest and veiniest get votes while fully clothed girls get shafted.

If you want my advice, rank all the winners by their percentage of votes received and give each girl an equal number of pics. I'd also do one last poll for women who didn't make it into your lists like Mimi Plastique, Jennifer Justice, Emily (Heavenly Sin), Juliana Dominguez, AlyssaTS, Alyssa87, SexyShana, Nicole Neuman, Susi1045 and that's just some of those who use to post here. Actually what this poll really is is the top 512 porn stars since that's really all the T's you seem to know.

BluegrassCat
06-04-2010, 06:59 AM
Great job, an impressive effort. I totally agree the rounds just be shorter. I'm not positive if these girls aren't included but I can't recall seeing them.

gjamestgirlfan
06-04-2010, 12:52 PM
This poll has been anything but fair. I can see your inherent bias towards your favorites by 1) the number of pictures for each (some girls have one and the ones you like have a dozen) and 2) whether or not they show their junk. Some people here think only of that so naturally the biggest, bushiest and veiniest get votes while fully clothed girls get shafted.

If you want my advice, rank all the winners by their percentage of votes received and give each girl an equal number of pics. I'd also do one last poll for women who didn't make it into your lists like Mimi Plastique, Jennifer Justice, Emily (Heavenly Sin), Juliana Dominguez, AlyssaTS, Alyssa87, SexyShana, Nicole Neuman, Susi1045 and that's just some of those who use to post here. Actually what this poll really is is the top 512 porn stars since that's really all the T's you seem to know.


Im sorry that felt that it isnt fair, i dont always have many pictures of certain girls, some i only have like 1 picture of, but i think is a nice looking girl so put in, also Natalie - Argentina i think is winning her group and only has one picture so i dont think that made a difference to her.
Yes also some pictures i have maybe old but its taken a lot of work and time to get this up, i thought people may add pictures to girls they liked if didnt think pictures i put on was doing girl justice.
If people choose to vote because of a girls cock that is fine, or if they vote on knowing the girl which i have read, also way looks facially also i do try if have some of the girls dressed before hand, but people can vote however they want or feel is sexy or attractive to them, thats part of fun of it all.
Also with regard to the following girls Mimi Plastique, Jennifer Justice, Emily (Heavenly Sin), Juliana Dominguez, AlyssaTS, Alyssa87, SexyShana, Nicole Neuman, Susi1045 feel free to add the girls in here and i will see about puting into competition as i have obviousally missed loads of girls out, also with your comment on that all i know is transexual porn stars, not quite correct as a lot of the girls on my competition so far people said never seen before, and i have met transgender girls myself but not going to put them in as, also these are the most girls to me or got my attention the most, i could so easily do another 512 girls, no problems, so always be some missing out, so i cant do an extra group purely for the girls you feel have missed out, i thank you for your comments, i do take on board but some of it is something i cant help eg amount of pictures have etc.
But feel free to post pictures and names of any girls you would like to be in the last 8 groups, well have a chance of being in, as already got list but can put into list and see if get drawn out.

gjamestgirlfan
06-04-2010, 02:32 PM
Camilla Saez has already been in, but i cant find what group she is in at the moment, i will check more for you later which one, unless someone else can help.

gjamestgirlfan
06-04-2010, 11:15 PM
Looks like im going to have to do seedings for the 2nd round, as that is what the majority asking for, will make the outcome a bit more obvious in the end and more work for me to try and organise how to do this, but i will see maybe a turn around in polls but i wanted to give everyone here a option.
Im still pleased 1st round was purely lucky dip draws, as given other girls a chance and not knowing who coming up against, i think the 2nd round is going to be a lot more obvious.

kitarana
06-06-2010, 08:33 PM
If there is still chance to add a girl, I would like that one of my faves Melanie could be in the competition also.

Anyway you're doing a great job with making these polls gjamestgirlfan.

lilhell
06-06-2010, 10:51 PM
Second round should be random like the first so there will be no favoritism.
As for wild card, I say yeah cause some of the girls deserve a second chance.
prehaps 2nd and 3rd place winners in the wildcard
Just my 2 cents.
PS I am trying to vote in all the groups as well :)

gjamestgirlfan
06-07-2010, 12:27 AM
Thanks Lilhell i wanted it to be random as well in 2nd round but i got a few comments by people saying that bit unfair so i thought id put it to a poll.
Gotta decide how to do the ranking, does make it that bit harder, but still time for polls to turn around, i liked the randomness of not knowing what group girls be in.
Also all the top girls still be in the next round like someone said the best girls will always win group anyway.

gjamestgirlfan
06-07-2010, 12:28 AM
Also Melanie is down in the list, so she will be in either of the last 2 groups 2mrw, 64 or 65.