PDA

View Full Version : Home from a tour in Iraq and killed for only having $8



Legend
06-02-2008, 06:29 AM
CLEVELAND (AP) — On leave from the violence he had survived in the war in Iraq, a young Marine was so wary of crime on the streets of his own home town that he carried only $8 to avoid becoming a robbery target.

Despite his caution, Lance Cpl. Robert Crutchfield, 21, was shot point-blank in the neck during a robbery at a bus stop. Feeding and breathing tubes kept him alive 4 1/2 months, until he died of an infection on May 18.

Two men have been charged in the attack, and Cuyahoga County Prosecutor Bill Mason said Friday the case was under review to decide whether to seek the death penalty.

"It is an awful story," said Alberta Holt, the young Marine's aunt and his legal guardian when he was a teenager determined to flee a troubled Cleveland school for safer surroundings in the suburbs.

Crutchfield was attacked on Jan. 5 while he and his girlfriend were waiting for a bus. He had heeded the warnings of commanders that a Marine on leave might be seen as a prime robbery target with a pocketful of money, so he only carried $8, his military ID card and a bank card.

"They took it, turned his pockets inside out, took what he had and told him since he was a Marine and didn't have any money he didn't deserve to live. They put the gun to his neck and shot him," Holt told The Associated Press.

The two men charged in the attack were identified as Ean Farrow, 19, and Thomas Ray III, 20, both of Cleveland. Their attorneys did not respond to The Associated Press' requests for comment.

Crutchfield knew he was returning to Iraq for another tour of duty, but had hesitated to tell his family until he was nearing the end of his 30-day leave.

He apparently had a troubled family. Holt wouldn't discuss it except to say "his mom and dad didn't raise him, just his grandmother and me." He didn't smoke or drink, she said.

He had attended Cleveland's inner-city East High School, but asked that he be allowed to live with his aunt and grandmother and attend suburban Bedford High School for his final two years.

"He saw his school was in turmoil and asked to get out," Holt said.

Bedford High teachers recalled Crutchfield's smile, his pride in his appearance, his determination to join the Marine Corps after graduation in 2005 and his aspiration to become an architect.

"He was friendly and kind and willing to help out in any way that he could," counselor Yvonne Sims said in an e-mail.

Connie LaNasa, who works in the school office, said Crutchfield was a well-behaved student and went about his school work with little notice.

"He lived out what he wanted to do and that is to be a Marine," LaNasa said.

Faculty members remembered Crutchfield as a top student in the computer design program, an office assistant and participant in the prom fashion show.

After his long hospitalization, an infection broke out a week before he died. "He said it felt like he was getting hit by lightning," Holt said.

When Crutchfield's body was laid out Tuesday in the Sacrificial Missionary Baptist Church, his white military dress hat was tugged down close to his eyes to conceal the skull flap that had been kept open to relieve swelling in his brain.

Marines provided an honor guard at his funeral service and carried the casket to his grave at the Western Reserve National Cemetery near Akron.

He was buried there on the same day as a Vietnam veteran, two veterans from World War II and three from Korea.
http://ap.google.com/article/ALeqM5hTCe8r8isQNFbv6Z9K5WLFyMeveAD911L2I80

Wow,Cleveland sucks.

justatransgirl
06-03-2008, 09:16 AM
That is so wrong.

What's also so sad is that far, far more people die from this sort of thing every year in the USA than all the US losses in Iraq since the war began.

Something needs to change.

Sigh,
TS Jamie :-(

manbearpig
06-03-2008, 03:38 PM
thats a damn shame...

sucka4chix
06-03-2008, 04:09 PM
Everything happens for a reason. When it's your time to go, it's your time to go! Why did some people survive the titanic and others didn't? You're gonna die at the apponted time in the appointed way.

manbearpig
06-03-2008, 07:47 PM
Everything happens for a reason. When it's your time to go, it's your time to go! Why did some people survive the titanic and others didn't? You're gonna die at the apponted time in the appointed way.

there is no reasonable justification for being murdered over 8 dollars. none whatsoever..

BeardedOne
06-03-2008, 09:19 PM
I won't even begin to attempt to unravel the theory of "...carried only $8 to avoid becoming a robbery target. ".

A robbery target is anything living or dead that has pockets.


Wow,Cleveland sucks.

Very, very, very old nooz.

I recall a similar incident in Philly a few years ago. A fellow recently discharged after his tour in Afghanistan was killed right outside his own house by the usual urban street trash.


Something needs to change.

Until society as a whole picks up on the wisdom that producing less garbage is more productive than storing old garbage, things will only get worse.

yodajazz
06-03-2008, 09:26 PM
I’m from Cleveland, but I had not heard about the story. I vaguely recall hearing about it when he was shot in January. I try to walk the streets often for exercise. I too do not carry a lot of money with me.

Such things make me reflect on what are ways to prevent such tragedies. The death penalty is not the answer. We already have it here. The killers didn’t have enough respect for life to worry about a death penalty. So as an answer I think that we should put money into education. But the focus of education should not be so focused on taking tests, it should be to give youth knowledge of the world, and various subjects, which would increase their skill base and hopefully give them more respect for life in general.
Lack of money has stripped the educational system of extra school activities that help students find interests outside of their classes.

I am not blaming anyone but the individuals who did the crime. But the solutions belong to us all, to value and respect life.