PDA

View Full Version : What in God's name is it about Brazil?



bat1million
08-04-2007, 02:39 AM
It just sems like the place is a mecca of shemale goddessees. I can't lie to myself anymore. they have t girls that rival ANY GG for beauty.

What is it about Brazil's culture that makes it so relaxed about the issue of t girls?

And I might as well ask, do you need to speak portugese fluenty to be able to survive?

I'm making it my mission in life to go down thier on the regular..;)

BrendaQG
08-04-2007, 02:53 AM
That seems to be a myth. I have never been to brazil but I have read part of this book called "travesti (http://www.amazon.com/Travesti-Brazilian-Transgendered-Prostitutes-Sexuality/dp/0226461009)" by Don Kulick and could not finish it because it was so depressing. It talked at length about the conditions those girls live in and it does not sound pretty. Though it does make it sound like they are happy none the less.

They have a truly hard life.

Now things may have changed but I can't imagine it could be by that much.

Ratbutt
08-04-2007, 06:00 AM
"Normal" society in Brazil is just as closeted as most other countries. Its not as if it is accepted that a man can marry a TG just as he would a GG.
In the nightlife it is understood that a man may have a TG or GG as his mistress though.
America, being backward, has this notion that genitalia=gender even though that is contrary to current medical knowledge.

Floyd R
08-04-2007, 08:03 AM
Check out http://www.glbtq.com/social-sciences/transsexuals_brazil.html
for an interesting read on the conditions faced by transgender people in Brazil.

emilyts
08-04-2007, 09:21 AM
Thats true their seems to be like 100 times more transsexuals down in Brazil then any other place, or is it because they all seem to do porn. cause in Thailand they do like small shows, like drag queens do here in America.

praetor
08-04-2007, 01:08 PM
Check out http://www.glbtq.com/social-sciences/transsexuals_brazil.html
for an interesting read on the conditions faced by transgender people in Brazil.

Excellent Barry Michael Wolfe point of view on the topic linked, the topic express the reality, the descrimination in Brazil, the article translate what happens the daily of the tgirls, and how they live. Glamour does not exist, is a legend, the real life is the poorness, pain, solitude, and the others social problems when they decide to be a travestite. You must read to understand the reality transgenders life in Brazil.

praetor
08-04-2007, 01:20 PM
:wink:

peggygee
08-04-2007, 08:50 PM
Transsexuals of Brazil

Barry Wolfe

http://www.glbtq.com/social-sciences/transsexuals_brazil.html



Transgender people in Brazil are the country's single most marginalized group. Fear, ignorance, and hypocrisy lead to discrimination and lack of education, which in turn render transgender people--more specifically, people who were born male but present themselves as female--subject to violence, social exclusion, drug abuse, crime, prostitution, exploitation, and severe health risks, each of which results in further discrimination.

Brazilian sexual culture contains deep and severely repressed androgynous elements. Transvestites, as many male-to-female transsexuals prefer to be called, are the personification of this cultural equivocation.

Definitions

While the term transgender as used in the United States and Europe has come to encompass all gender-variant individuals, including female-to-male transsexuals, drag queens and kings, and intersex individuals, in Brazil the social phenomenon of transgênero largely consists of individuals who were born male but who live their lives as women.

Transgender people in Brazil fall into two categories: travestis (i.e., transvestites) and transsexuals, although for many the two terms are interchangeable. To the extent that the latter insist on distinguishing themselves from transvestites, it is because transsexuals consider that they were born into the wrong body, whereas transvestites do not experience as deeply internal conflicts in relation to their male bodies.

In practice, both transvestites and transsexuals make commitments to living and dressing exclusively as women, and are accordingly distinguished from "drags" (i.e., classic transvestites) in two respects. First, drags dress and appear as men in normal life and only "mount" themselves as women in specific situations. Second, transvestites and transsexuals generally make significant changes to their bodies, often through massive hormone intake, silicone enhancement, plastic surgery, and, sometimes, sex reassignment surgery, whereas "drags" do not.

"Transgender people" is the translation of the Portuguese generic term transgênero. The term underscores the fact that these individuals are, indeed, people--often highly sensitive, intelligent, creative people--who are routinely stripped of the most basic consideration as human beings.

Discrimination

Transgender people in Brazil face discrimination and humiliation, usually beginning in early childhood when they first appear to be different. At schools, they are obliged to use their natal identity or be referred to by a number. The most immediate result of this discrimination is that the formal education of most transgender people extends little beyond basic literacy, and a considerable number are, in fact, illiterate.

As they grow older and have to deal with public authorities, they suffer discrimination in bars, restaurants, and entertainment establishments where they are often required to use male entrances and male toilets and submit to being frisked by men.

Adult transgender people are discriminated against by heterosexuals and homosexuals alike. The result is that many tend to live in their own hermetically sealed world with minimal points of contact with mainstream society.

They are excluded from many religious communities, and are warmly welcomed only by the Afro-Brazilian churches.

Culture

Transgender people have their own street vocabulary, pajuba, to denote the terms and conditions most common to their life, such as men, women, sexual organs, good, bad, etc. Much of this terminology has origins in Afro-Brazilian religious culture and is shared by street prostitutes.

Some transgender people communicate in an exclusive language constructed by placing an expression before or after each word they speak. For example, they may converse using "semi" after each word. This practice, combined with their specialized vocabulary, renders it impossible for outsiders to understand what they say.

Transgender people who have not undergone sex-change surgery do not consider themselves women. However, they categorize non-transgender men as "he" or "she" according to whether the man assumes an active or passive role in sexual relations. In other words, when transgender people speak of males, gender is considered a question of process; when they speak of females, however, they categorize them as ontologically different, defined by virtue of their vaginas. Racha (literally translated as "split") is the pajuba term for both a woman and a vagina.

Prostitution

The formal labor market is largely closed to transgender people. An extremely small minority of transvestites have university educations or professional qualifications. With few exceptions, the only professions open to them are nursing, domestic service, hairdressing, gay entertainment, and prostitution. In some cases, even those who work as hairdressers, gay night club artists, and domestic servants also double as sex workers.

In the central, north, and northeastern regions of Brazil, transgender people from extremely poor families sometimes begin working as prostitutes as early as 12 years of age, especially if they have been expelled from home by their families. In the south and southeastern regions and in the major capitals of São Paulo and Rio de Janeiro, it is common to find transvestites as young as 16 or 17 working the streets.

peggygee
08-04-2007, 08:53 PM
http://www.glbtq.com/social-sciences/transsexuals_brazil,2.html

Transvestites' clients are generally men who appear as "straight" in society. Many, if not most, are married. Contrary to what one might expect, in the majority of instances, the transvestite sex worker performs the active role in sexual intercourse, the male client assuming the passive, receptive role.

AIDS experts believe that a significant hidden route of transmission of AIDS in Brazil is through transgender prostitution: the transvestite passes HIV to the client and the client in turn passes the virus to his wife or partner.

Unlike female sex workers, who have a range of professional options available to them, transgender sex workers often feel they have no options. Many see prostitution as the price they pay for choosing to transform. Moreover, whereas female sex workers have a wide range of options within the profession--the street, various types of night clubs and brothels, advertising in newspapers and on the Internet--transvestites generally work the streets and low-end brothels, known as "privés."

Their relegation to low-end prostitution has three particularly adverse implications for transvestites: endemic violence, pimping, and trafficking, all of which are aggravated by severely restricted access to good medical services.

Violence and Criminality

Transgender prostitutes working the streets are routinely subject to violence from the police, clients, passers-by, and, sometimes, from pimps. Such violence includes beatings, intimidation, torture, and shootings.

In some cases the violence is random and indiscriminate. Some groups of men consider it fun to beat up transvestites or conduct drive-by shootings. Similarly, some individual clients indulge in sadistic behavior.

In other cases, the violence may take the form of organized or spontaneous punishment or reprisals against transvestites who sometimes rob and assault their clients. Recently, in São Paulo, for example, groups of transvestites surrounded cars that stopped at traffic lights and robbed the drivers. Such acts result in reprisals by individuals and in violent repression by the police. In both cases, the violence targets all transgender people in the region in question and is not limited to criminal elements.

Formal complaints are rarely lodged by transgender people against the police due to a combination of discrimination, police corruption, and fear of reprisals.

Street pimps also sometimes beat up transvestites who fail to pay their obligations.

Pimping

In Brazil, there are two kinds of pimps: male pimps, known as cafetões; and transvestite pimps, known as cafetinas. Cafetões are generally low-level drug dealers. Cafetinas run boarding houses for transvestites.

Especially in the major cities, all prostitutes who work the streets are required to pay a pimping fee. This is generally a fixed weekly fee that buys the right to work a particular area where the pimp in question has rights. In return for the fee, the pimp confers protection from harassment from other pimps and, in principle, from the police. Female sex workers pay the fee to cafetões. Transvestites pay the fee either to a cafetão or to a cafetina who has street rights, i.e. one who is respected by the cafetões.

Many transvestites live in houses run by cafetinas. The cafetina charges a daily fee for board and lodging. Where the cafetina does not have street rights, the transvestite must also pay a weekly fee to a cafetão.

Pimping fees can represent an excessive burden for a transvestite sex worker. In extreme cases, where the transvestite has to pay both a cafetina and a cafetão in an area where the price of a trick (programa) is low, she may have to perform as many as 60 programas per month--i.e., two a day, seven days a week--just to cover pimping and transport costs.

Whereas the relationship between the sex worker and the cafetão is essentially based on fear and intimidation, the relationship between the sex worker and the cafetina is sometimes quite different. In many cases the cafetina provides a significant level of guidance and emotional support, especially when the transvestite has moved from a distant region to the major cities of São Paulo or Rio de Janeiro.

In these instances, the cafetina functions as a parent figure, especially if, as is often the case, the transvestite has effectively been expelled from her family, usually at an early age. In these relationships, the cafetina is referred to as the Madrinha (Godmother) and the transvestite considers herself a filha (daughter).

Crucial to whether her transvestites will be guided towards or away from criminal behavior and drug abuse is the character and outlook of the cafetina.

peggygee
08-04-2007, 08:55 PM
http://www.glbtq.com/social-sciences/transsexuals_brazil,3.html


Trafficking

Transvestites are often sent by cafetinas in the central, north, and northeastern state capitals to their counterparts in São Paulo and Rio de Janeiro where they work the streets, take massive doses of hormones, and have their bodies transformed by silicone pumping, breast implants, and other plastic surgery. They are then sent to on to other cafetinas based in Europe, principally Italy, France, Switzerland, Germany, Spain, and Portugal.

The entire process of traveling to and working in Europe is organized by the cafetinas. The transvestite typically flies to a country that is not her final destination and then enters the final destination clandestinely. Thereafter, the Brazilian cafetina's European counterpart arranges for accommodation and work, which, depending on the country or region, may be on the street or in a brothel.

If the transvestite is unable to pay for the pumping, plastic surgery, and transport to Europe, she may be financed by the cafetinas. Effective interest rates vary, but they are always excessive.

Once the loans have been paid, the transvestite is free and is not tied to a particular cafetina structure. The transvestite who manages not to become addicted to narcotics or to be infected by HIV and to steer clear of violence stands a reasonable chance of returning to Brazil with enough money to purchase a house and a car. They frequently also send money to the same parents who rejected them.

Silicone Pumping and Plastic Surgery

Silicone pumping, by which buttocks, legs, and sometimes breasts and faces are transformed, is a staple of many transvestites' lives, especially those who engage in sex work. Some transvestites become specialists, known as bombardeiras (pumpers), in pumping industrial silicone into the bodies of other transgender people.

There are a number of adverse effects of silicone pumping, including silicone dropping down into the ankles and feet, the immune system's rejection of silicone, and the risk of silicone entering the bloodstream or vital organs.

Breast implants and facial surgery are generally performed by licensed (and also possibly unlicensed) plastic surgeons who specialize exclusively in attending transgender people.

Health and Drug Abuse

Transgender people's health is precarious not merely because of silicone pumping and massive hormone intake, but also because they often have no private health insurance, and hence are reluctant to see physicians for regular checkups or to treat chronic conditions. The general discrimination and humiliation they experience in dealing with the government bureaucracy often serves to dissuade them from seeking assistance from the public health service.

Moreover, transgender people who work as prostitutes are especially susceptible to drug abuse and sexually transmitted diseases (STDs), including HIV infection.

NGOs, Government Agencies, and the Pursuit of Rights

The deep structural social problems faced by the poor in Brazil, combined with the isolation and discrimination encountered by transgender people, conspire against their attainment of the most basic human and legal rights.

There are a number of NGOs (i.e., non-government organizations) and federal, state, and municipal government agencies that offer various forms of advice and assistance to transgender people, mostly as part of STD/AIDS prevention and assistance programs. These agencies, therefore, tend to focus on condom use and safe-sex measures rather than addressing questions of marginalization, prostitution, violence, and discrimination.

Specific government programs range from general projects aimed at increasing the sensitivity of health workers when dealing with the glbtq community and promoting education about sexual diversity and legal rights to specific programs intended to limit the damage done by silicone pumping. There are also programs that fund NGOs to work with the glbtq community to reduce vulnerability to STD/AIDS.

Many NGOs relied on funding from the U. S. government through USAID's contribution to the Brazilian Government's National AIDS Policy. In 2005, however, USAID funding was withdrawn as a result of the Brazilian Government's refusal to endorse the Bush administration's requirement that AIDS programs emphasize abstinence, faithfulness, the use of condoms only when necessary, and opposition to the decriminalization of prostitution. Brazil was the first country openly to oppose the U. S. abstinence policy, which caused it to lose a grant of $40,000,000.

Transgender Activism and the Glbtq Movement

Transgender political activism in Brazil only began in the 1990s, as a result of the AIDS epidemic, whereas gay and lesbian mobilization for equal rights dates from the 1970s. Although transgender people frequently add color and excitement to the massive Gay Pride celebrations in Brazil's major cities, they have been less successful than gay men and lesbians in winning a degree of public acceptance and legal rights.

JelenaCD
08-04-2007, 08:56 PM
OK, I know i will be in the minority here yet i don't really care for T-Gals from Brazil , so over rated to me ! Dominican gals are so much better !

peggygee
08-04-2007, 08:58 PM
http://www.glbtq.com/social-sciences/transsexuals_brazil,4.html


There are relatively few activist groups in Brazil that encompass the whole range of alternative sexualities and genders. Within these mixed groups, transsexuals tend to distinguish themselves from transvestites, hence the increasing use of the term "GLBTT"--Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, Transvestite, and Transsexual--rather than the acronym most familiar in the United States, "GLBT"--Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Transgender, where "Transgender" is used as an umbrella term.

Despite being included in Brazil's acronym in the struggle for glbtq rights, transgender people receive little outreach from the more mainstream gay and lesbian groups. There are, however, associations of transgender people in several Brazilian states and cities.

One program in Rio de Janeiro focuses on the reintegration of transvestites into society through training and employment opportunities.

Emotional Life

The dire political and social situation of transgender people in Brazil could gradually be alleviated if more transgender people qualified as doctors, lawyers, and other professionals. However, in addition to the discrimination that limits their education, most transvestites seem unwilling to make the sacrifices necessary to obtain higher education. They seem to believe that to do so would also mean sacrificing the most important years of their lives as beautiful women.

The combined effects of discrimination, humiliation, lack of education, and isolation from mainstream society place enormous emotional strain on Brazil's transgender people, especially those who earn their living as sex workers. They tend to live for the present, in the belief that their beauty will not last long and in the knowledge that prospects for a decent life beyond 30 are extremely limited.

The pressures to succumb to drug abuse and criminality are enormous, but transgender people are also especially vulnerable to contracting AIDS and to falling into cynicism and despair. Avoiding these pitfalls demands remarkable courage and strength of character.

peggygee
08-04-2007, 09:00 PM
Bibliography


Brasil, Mariana. O manuscrito de Sônia: Prostituição, erotismo e amor. São Paulo: Italianova, 2005.

Couto, Edvaldo Souza. Transexualidade: o corpo em mutação. Salvador: GrupoGay da Bahia, 1999.

Foureaux de Souza, J. L., Jr., ed. Literatura e homoerotismo: umaintrodução. São Paulo: Scortecci, 2002.

Garcia, Wilton. Corpo, mídia e representação: estudos contemporâneos. São Paulo: Thompson, 2005.

Green, James N. Beyond Carnival: Male Homosexuality in Twentieth-Century Brazil. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1999.

Kulick, Don. Travesti: Sex, Gender, and Culture among Brazilian Transgendered Prostitutes. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1998.

_____, and Charles Klein. Scandalous Acts: The Politics of Shame among Brazilian Travesti Prostitutes. http://www.socant.su.se.

Lancaster, Roger. "Transgenderism in Latin America: Some Critical Introductory Remarks on Identities and Practices." Sexualities 1.3 (1998): 261-274.

Lopes, Denílson, Wilton Garcia, Sérgio Aboud, and Berenice Bento, eds. Imagem & diversidade sexual: estudos da homocultura. São Paulo: Nojosaedições, 2002.

Lyra, Bernadette and Wilton Garcia, eds. Corpo e cultura. São Paulo: Xamã-ECA/USP, 2001.

McCallum, Cecília. "Travesti: Sex, Gender and Culture among Brazilian Transgendered Prostitutes." Mana 5.1 (1999): 165-68.

Moreno, Antônio. A personagem homossexual no cinema brasileiro. Rio de Janeiro: Funarte, Niterói: EdUFF, 2001.

Mott, Luiz R. B. Epidemic of Hate: Violations of the Human Rights of Gay Men, Lesbians and Transvestites in Brazil. San Francisco: Grupo Gay da Bahia/International Gay and Lesbian Human Rights Commission, 1996.

_____, and Marcelo Cerqueira. As travestis da Bahia e a Aids. Salvador: Ministério da Saúde e Grupo Gay da Bahia, 1997.

Reis, Paulo. Mapa da Violência e Discriminação Praticada contra Gays, Lésbicas, Travestis, Transexuais e Bissexuais. São Paulo: Centro de Referência GLTTB da Secretaria da Cidadania Trabalho, Assistência e Inclusão Social da Prefeitura Municipal de Campinas, 2006.

Santos, Rick, and Wilton Garcia, eds. A escrita de adé: perspectivas teóricasdos estudos gays e lésbicas no Brasil. São Paulo: Xamã-Nassau Community CollegeNCC/SUNY, 2002.

Trevisan, João Silvério. Devassos no paraíso: A homossexualidade no Brasil, da colônia à atualidade. São Paulo: Record, 2000.



Citation Information

Author: Wolfe, Barry Michael
Entry Title: Transsexuals of Brazil
General Editor: Claude J. Summers
Publication Name: glbtq: An Encyclopedia of Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual,
Transgender, and Queer Culture
Publication Date: 2006
Date Last Updated December 26, 2006
Web Address www.glbtq.com/social-sciences/transsexuals_brazil.html
Publisher glbtq, Inc.
1130 West Adams
Chicago, IL 60607
Today's Date August 4, 2007
Encyclopedia Copyright: © 2002-2006, glbtq, Inc.
Entry Copyright © 2006 glbtq, Inc.

Tepres
08-04-2007, 09:00 PM
i hope to go there someday :)

BrendaQG
08-05-2007, 12:00 AM
:-/ I dont like the way that was written. It seems to somewhat ethnocentriacally intrepret the culture of the travestis (NOT TRANSVESTITES :roll: ) through the lens of the POV of white north american transsexual or excuse me transgendered women.

But that's beside the point.

The thing about brazil is it is a catholic country that likes to party on saturday then curse to hell the people they party with on sunday. Just like the good ol USA.

peggygee
08-05-2007, 12:47 AM
...the travestis (NOT TRANSVESTITES :roll: ) through the lens of the POV of white north american transsexual or excuse me transgendered women.





The long historical use of the English word “transvestite” seriously
complicates efforts at communication and translation across language
barriers. The reason is that it is easily confused with the word “travesti”,
which is used in many Romance languages (Spanish, Portuguese, Italian,
etc.).

In the Portuguese and Spanish-speaking worlds, the word “travesti” has long
been used to refer to gender-variant males (just as “transvestite” was long
used in the English speaking world). However, “travesti” has a very
different meaning in the Romance languages than “transvestite” has in
English.

Instead of referring to heterosexual crossdressers ( “transvestites”),
“travestis” refers to young gender transitioners who are attracted to
men, who feminize their bodies and partly transition (usually without
genital surgery) and who historically have worked in the sex trade.

Thus “travesti” is best translated into the word “she-male” (although
that word has a negative connotation in English).


http://www.hungangels.com/board/viewtopic.php?t=21656&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=10

BrendaQG
08-05-2007, 03:50 AM
Yes Cosign! Thankyou for saying it in a way I just could not. My reaction was colored by my own lens of personal experinece. :oops:

peggygee
08-05-2007, 05:04 PM
http://i92.photobucket.com/albums/l2/magi43/unaids_logo_en.jpg

Fighting stigma against sexual minorities in Latin America


Marcela Romero became a woman in heart, soul and body at the age of 17. This decision changed her life completely. No longer would ‘Marcelo’ (her name at birth) be the favourite uncle or pride of the family. Instead Marcela faced scorn and rejection.

“Knowing that your family wishes you had never existed or listening to the constant question what did I do to have a person like this in the family is very painful,” Marcela explained.

After having to drop out from school in Argentina due to reaction to her new appearance, Marcela was forced to sell sex to survive financially. During this time, Marcela became HIV positive.

Marcela’s experiences are typical of transsexuals in Latin America and other parts of the world as they face rejection from their families, marginalization within wider society and other forms of stigma and discrimination.

http://i92.photobucket.com/albums/l2/magi43/brazil.jpg

This is the reality of the gay, lesbian and transsexual population in Latin America. We are permanently treated as fascinating objects for investigation or contempt and not as individuals with rights,” said Marcela, explaining that despite her wish to be considered a woman, she is still obliged to carry and present her male identification papers to keep within the country’s law. In Latin America, stigma and discrimination of sexual minorities often goes hand in hand with HIV-related discrimination.

“Sexual violence is a reality for many sexual minorities and often sex work is the only viable option to make a living for transgender and transsexual people who are marginalized in mainstream society. Unless HIV prevention and stigma eradication programmes are designed by and for these communities they will continue to be more vulnerable to HIV,” said UNAIDS Head of Civil Society Partnerships, Andy Seale.

Marcela is working hard with others in the same situation as her to respond to and reduce the kind of stigma and discrimination she faces every day. As coordinator of the Latin American Transsexual Network (REDLACTRANS), she recently took part in a meeting in Brazil, in which other representatives from more than 20 Latin American countries gathered to address the issue of discrimination against sexual minorities and its effects on the AIDS response.

http://i92.photobucket.com/albums/l2/magi43/bazil2.jpg

right to left): Dr Pedro Chequer, UNAIDS Country Coordinator for
Argentina, Chile, Uruguay and Paraguay; Marcela Romero, Coordinator of
the Latin American Transsexual Network (REDLACTRANS


Within the discussions at the meeting, a strategic guidebook to help fight discrimination against sexual minorities, and reduce its impact on HIV, was presented for discussion. “This guidebook will be a useful instrument for countries, especially those that lack on legislations and laws that ensure the basic human rights to these important populations,” said Pedro Chequer, UNAIDS Country Coordinator for Argentina, Chile, Uruguay and Paraguay. More than 80 countries around the world, especially in Asia, Africa, Central America and the Caribbean, currently punish homosexuality as a crime.

The meeting was an initiative of the Horizontal Technical Cooperation Group (HTCG), that comprises more than 21 Latin American countries, and the UNAIDS Regional Support Team for Latin America. The guidebook is expected to be ready for distribution later this year.

“We are committed to stopping the crimes and abuses against gay, lesbian and transsexual populations which can lead to a higher HIV risk. This goal can only be achieved through public policies that respect sexual orientation and human rights,” said Carlos Passarelli, HTCG’s Joint Director.

Arturo Diaz, from the Mexican non-governmental organization, Letra S, stated that this type of discrimination “affects the daily lives of the gay, lesbian and transsexual populations in personal, emotional and professional aspects, as well as health”.

As stated in the Declaration of Commitment on AIDS, UNAIDS is working on initiatives to join efforts with governments, civil society and the media of all the Latin American countries to fight stigma and discrimination through coordinated action as part of a wide response to the AIDS epidemic.

The path ahead is long, but as Marcela has seen, stigma and discrimination can be broken down gradually, moving towards the ultimate goal of total eradication. “Before only my best friend would accept me, now my Mum has started to come around as well,” she said. “Things are changing – it’s little by little, but they are changing for the better.”

hondarobot
08-05-2007, 07:16 PM
Not being from Brazil, or ever having visited myself, I don't know how accurate this is, but the movie "City Of God" paints a very grim picture of life for the urban poor in that country.

It's a very well made movie, but it certainly isn't a feel good story by any means.